OIG: FY2025 AUDITS OF SOLE-SOURCE AFFILIATE HEALTHCARE PROPOSALS FLAGGED $183.9 MILLION IN POTENTIAL SAVINGS; VA SUSTAINED $28.1 MILLION ON 21 AWARDS

By VA Headlines staff · Published Nov 20, 2026 · Source dated October 1, 2026 (VA Office of Inspector General)

Preaward audits of 27 sole-source healthcare proposals from VA-affiliated institutions in fiscal year 2025 flagged more than $183.9 million in potential savings out of a combined estimated contract value of about $488.4 million, the VA Office of Inspector General reported on October 1, 2026. As of June 2026, VA had awarded 21 of those contracts and sustained about $28.1 million in savings -- a fraction of the $155.3 million in potential savings the OIG had identified on those 21 awards alone.

The summary review, VA OIG 26-01671-165, Summary of Fiscal Year 2025 Preaward Audits for Healthcare Resource Proposals from Affiliates, was deferred to fiscal year 2026 so the office could report realized savings after contracts were negotiated and awarded. The 27 individual preaward audits are not published because they contain sensitive personal data of physicians and other clinical staff. This summary makes no new recommendations. The executive director of VA's Office of Procurement concurred with the draft, with one technical comment, which the OIG said it addressed.

This is an audit of pricing and ethics process on sole-source affiliate contracts, not a finding of criminal wrongdoing. Conflict-of-interest flags in 17 of the 27 proposals are flags, not proven misconduct, and this report does not treat them as such.

Key findings

  • The OIG completed 27 preaward audits in FY2025: 22 proposals with full-time-equivalent, or hourly, pricing and five with per-procedure pricing. Combined estimated contract value was about $488.4 million. Potential savings identified: more than $183.9 million.
  • As of June 2026, VA awarded 21 contracts and sustained about $28.1 million of the $155.3 million in potential savings on those 21 awards, based in part on the OIG's work. One proposal, on which the OIG identified an opportunity for $23.8 million in estimated savings, was still in negotiation. The remaining five solicitations were canceled, so savings on those are unknown.
  • For all 22 hourly proposals, the OIG determined the prices offered were higher than the supported amounts. The most common issue was unsupported provider salaries; other frequent issues included unsupported administrative expenses and incentives. The OIG recommended obtaining lower prices than offered on all 22.
  • For all five per-procedure proposals, the OIG determined the prices offered were higher than properly calculated Medicare rates under the VHA Procurement Manual, and recommended obtaining lower prices on all five.
  • In 17 of 27 proposals, the OIG found potential conflicts of interest for VA staff who held faculty appointments at the affiliate institutions, and for which the contracting officer had not yet sought an Office of General Counsel opinion as policy requires. Among the other 10 proposals, the OIG did not identify potential conflicts. Some proposals involved more than one VA employee.

How sole-source affiliate contracts work

Healthcare resources for commercial services can be competed. Under 38 U.S.C. § 8153(a)(3)(A), however, VA may procure healthcare resources from affiliates -- colleges and schools of medicine, among other affiliated institutions -- on a sole-source basis without regard to laws or regulations that require competition. VA Directive 1663 still requires that sole-source affiliate contracts for healthcare resource services not associated with a residency program demonstrate "the best value to the government."

The VHA Procurement Manual requires contracting officers to request an OIG review or audit for any sole-source healthcare proposal with an anticipated annual value of at least $750,000. The audits give contracting officers information to use in negotiation; the outcome of any proposal is subject to that negotiation. "Full-time-equivalent," or hourly, pricing means VA pays based on the number of full-time staff needed for day-to-day clinical operations that existing VA staff cannot perform. "Per-procedure" pricing means VA pays for the procedure itself, such as a treatment or transplant, rather than a physician's time.

The OIG team discussed documentation with affiliate representatives and VA contracting officers and evaluated it against applicable law, acquisition regulations, Medicare guidelines, and VA policy. The summary work was done from March through June 2026. Assistant Inspector General Larry M. Reinkemeyer signed the report.

The gap between potential savings and dollars sustained

The headline potential figure -- more than $183.9 million -- is the difference the OIG drew between offered prices and the prices it recommended, across all 27 proposals. What VA actually banked is smaller. On the 21 contracts already awarded, the OIG had identified $155.3 million in potential savings. Contracting officers sustained about $28.1 million, "based, in part, on the OIG's audits." The report presents that figure as what negotiation produced, not as a finding that officers ignored the audits. One remaining proposal still in play carries $23.8 million in estimated OIG-identified savings. For the five canceled solicitations, reasons included switching to a competitive acquisition, electing not to pursue a contract with the affiliate, hiring full-time employees, and significant scope changes.

Some of the potential never became a contract. Some is still on the table. On the awards that did go through, the government sustained about 18 percent of the potential savings the OIG had flagged on those same 21 contracts. Both numbers are in the official record: the $183.9 million identified, and the $28.1 million realized as of June 2026.

Conflict-of-interest flags, not findings of guilt

VHA Directive 1660.03 notes that federal law prohibits an employee from participating personally and substantially in a particular matter in which the employee has a conflict of interest, including a contract that would have a direct and predictable effect on the employee's own financial interest or certain related interests. The OIG reviewed the 27 proposals "to safeguard against fraud and improper influence in VA's acquisition process."

In 17 proposals, it found potential conflicts for VA staff who held faculty appointments at the affiliate -- people who may also be responsible for monitoring the resulting contract -- and found that the contracting officer had not yet sought the written Office of General Counsel deputy ethics official opinion that policy requires. The OIG notified the contracting officers and recommended that they request those opinions. Dual roles, the report says, "may influence or appear to influence procurement decisions." The point of the referral is to determine whether a financial interest would disqualify the employee from participating.

Those are potential conflicts identified in a preaward review, not determinations that anyone broke the law. Individual audit reports were withheld because they contain sensitive personal information. This story does not name clinicians or treat a flag as a finding of wrongdoing.

Why it matters

Sole-source authority exists for a reason: VA's academic affiliates supply physicians, specialty care, and teaching relationships that can be hard to buy on the open market. The same authority removes ordinary competition, which is why the $750,000 audit threshold and the "best value" rule exist. When all 22 hourly proposals and all five per-procedure proposals came in above what the OIG says is supported -- and when 17 of 27 files raised ethics-opinion issues that had not yet been referred -- the question is whether the department is paying a fair price, and whether the people overseeing the deal are cleanly separated from the institution being paid. The $28.1 million already sustained is real. The distance between that figure and the $155.3 million identified on the same awards is also real.

What VA said

Jeffrey C. Neill, executive director of the Office of Procurement, issued VA's comments in an August 31, 2026, memorandum. The office concurred with the draft report with one technical comment: it recommended removal of a sentence concerning justification for using sole-source procedures if awarding to an affiliate. The OIG said it incorporated revised language to address that comment. Because the published report is a summary of unpublished audits already provided to VA, it made no recommendations that required a new action plan.

What's next

One proposal with $23.8 million in OIG-identified potential savings was still in negotiation as of June 2026. Additional savings might be sustained on that award. Contracting officers were advised to seek Office of General Counsel ethics opinions where potential conflicts were flagged; this summary does not report whether those opinions have since been obtained. There are no open recommendations on 26-01671-165 to track.

Sources

Related: Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) News. More: all VA Headlines reports. How we report: Methodology & Corrections.

INFO CARD
Agency / office: VA Office of Inspector General, Office of Audits and Evaluations
Program: Sole-source healthcare resource contracts with affiliates (38 U.S.C. § 8153)
Document type: OIG summary review of FY2025 preaward audits
Report no.: 26-01671-165
Date issued: October 1, 2026
Status / outcome: No new recommendations. Office of Procurement concurred with one technical comment, which the OIG addressed. Conflict-of-interest issues in 17 of 27 proposals are flags, not findings of wrongdoing.
OFFICIAL SOURCESVA Office of Inspector General
Summary of Fiscal Year 2025 Preaward Audits for Healthcare Resource Proposals from Affiliates — 26-01671-165, October 1, 2026
Read the OIG report page
Read the official PDF
Facts on this page come only from the OIG report. VA Headlines reports only what official records say. Spot an error? See our corrections policy.
VA Headlines staff